Write music, let the sweetness come through

The miracle of Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure. When do good ideas go from sweet to sour? Is it possible to preserve the sweetness of your original idea through its execution? Bill S Preston, Esq and Ted “Theodore” Logan III (and one of their creators, Ed Solomon) might just be able to help us answer these questions.

It is a miracle that any film is ever made. Let alone a good one. The idea for a film is likely to be changed and compromised beyond all recognition* as it proceeds from concept to celluloid.**

The miracle of Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure


Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure is a miracle. It is not just a good film, but a perfect one. . The dialogue is roughly 100 times better than it has any need to be – witty, eloquent and endlessly quotable. The film abounds with charm and innocence. The plot hinges on a logic that I can only describe as a joyously dumb kind of clever.

In the latest episode of Brian Koppelman’s excellent The Moment podcast, Ed Solomon – who co-wrote both Bill and Ted movies (to date) with Chris Matheson – explains how Bill and Ted came to be. It was all there in the initial idea. Solomon and Matheson would perform sketches as these characters:

“One of the sketches we did was two guys who know nothing about history, studying history. Chris was Bill, I was Ted, just randomly. Chris and I just loved doing the characters. There was something fun and sweet. And there was something infectious.”

They eventually decided to turn these fun, sweet and infectious characters into a screenplay. Inspiration struck, and fast:

“We just blasted it in a week. We did an outline in three days and a handwritten script in four.”

Solomon describes how Bill &Ted’s Excellent Adventure struggled through the stages of being turned into a film. Just after the script was completed, his agent left him the following message:

“Do you hear this sound? That’s the sound of me falling on my knees, begging you not to show this to anyone.”

The sweetness came through in a big way


Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure somehow got made.

If you create anything and see it through to execution, its flaws will be painfully apparent to you once it’s out in the world. I know this all too well from sharing my blog posts and drawings online. Solomon had just this experience when Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure was released. I love his description of how his relationship to the film has changed over time:

“When I look back at it, I’m deeply grateful, and I think ‘My god, we hit a much higher percentage of our intention than I ever would have expected.’ But at the time it didn’t feel like it. At the time, it felt like a series of compromises that we had to make to placate the studio and various different people involved in the production. In hindsight, would our version, if we’d fought, have been better? I don’t know. We [had in mind] a more sort of raucous, unpolished film. But what we got was a really lovely [film]. The sweetness came through in a big way. The sweetness, the tone, the voice – that actually was the thing that was preserved, and was the most important thing of all.”

I’d never thought of it this way, but that sweetness is the key to the magic of both Bill and Ted films. It is the most important thing of all.


All ideas go through a similar journey from conception, through evolution and/or mutation to execution. If an idea can be expressed as clearly as possible at an early stage, it has a better chance of surviving to the end product.

Writing the right words can help capture the idea, and give it a fighting chance. In the case of Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure, the dialogue penned by Solomon and Matheson was alive from the start with its own kind of music.

This brings me to some superb words from the late Gary Provost on creating music in the written word, which I came across via a Twitter share from David D’Souza this week.


The website dedicated to Gary Provost and his work offers a slightly longer version of these words:

“This sentence has five words. Here are five more words. Five-word sentences are fine. But several together become monotonous. Listen to what is happening. The writing is getting boring. The sound of it drones. It’s like a stuck record. The ear demands some variety. Now listen. I vary the sentence length, and I create music. Music. The writing sings. It has a pleasant rhythm, a lilt, a harmony. I use short sentences. And I use sentences of medium length. And sometimes when I am certain the reader is rested, I will engage him with a sentence of considerable length, a sentence that burns with energy and builds with all the impetus of a crescendo, the roll of the drums, the crash of the cymbals–sounds that say listen to this, it is important.

“So write with a combination of short, medium, and long sentences. Create a sound that pleases the reader’s ear. Don’t just write words. Write music.”

Write the right words.

Don’t just write words.

Write music.

Let the sweetness come through.


* David Hughes’ excellent books Tales From Development Hell and The Greatest Sci-Fi Movies Never Made provide an insight into just how unlikely the existence of any film really is.

** Gentle reader, please forgive me my dated turn of phrase. Clearly, the contingency that any film is produced on celluloid nowadays is a remote one. But the word “celluloid” has such a nice ring.

*** Spoiler alert: Please only read this footnote if you have either seen or have no intention of ever seeing the Amy Adams film Arrival. Still here? When I saw Arrival – a good little film, and a visually beautiful one – I found the big twist/reveal on which the entire plot hinges to be remarkably reminiscent of a scene in Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure. Specifically, the scene in which Bill and Ted make a mental note to their future selves to hop back in time and leave the keys to Ted’s dad’s car in the bushes, so that they can find them right now and make their getaway*****. There is another great episode of Brian Koppelman’s podcast featuring Arrival screenwriter Eric Heisserer talking about how that film made it from idea to screen. But I do not believe that any potential inspiration from Bill and Ted cropped up in that particular chat. I do hope that there is an Arrival/Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure connection – always great to take inspiration from the very best!

**** And I have every confidence that it will be present and correct in the forthcoming third film in this sequence: Bill & Ted Face The Music.

***** Yes, a footnote to a footnote. Chris Matheson offers the following description of this absurd logic in the unambiguously-titled Making of Bill & Ted – The Most Triumphant Making of Documentary (which some enterprising – if perhaps copyright-defying – soul has uploaded to YouTube):

“It’s kind of brilliant, in a way. It doesn’t make much sense. But it’s kind of brilliant.”


  • The three ages of the strawberry (as the strawberry makes its way to sweetness), as photographed recently in the garden of MJCarty.
  • Bodacious Bill and Ted images: I make no claim to the copyright for this image, and will remove it from this post immediately, if required.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s